A fixed-term agreement runs for a set period or until a specific event, with the reason stated in writing, while a casual agreement has no guaranteed hours and the employee can decline any shift offered. Employment New Zealand treats choosing the wrong type as grounds for the role to become permanent.
If you run a cafe doing seasonal brunch trade, a shop gearing up for the Christmas rush, or a building site that needs an extra pair of hands until the frame is up, you've probably wondered which agreement actually fits. Getting it wrong is more than paperwork sloppiness. It can mean an employee you thought was casual is legally entitled to redundancy, notice and ongoing hours.
What's the real difference between fixed term and casual?
A fixed-term agreement is still a genuine employment relationship with set hours, it just ends on a known date or when a known event finishes, like "until the extension is signed off" or "until 20 January 2027". You have to state the actual reason in the agreement itself, not just tick a box. A vague reason, or using fixed term as a disguised trial period, is exactly what gets challenged.
Casual employment has no ongoing expectation of work at all. There's no roster promise, no set hours, and the person can say no to a shift without consequence, same as you can choose not to offer one. The test isn't what you call it on the contract, it's whether there's a genuine pattern of regular work. If a "casual" barista has worked the same three shifts a week for four months, that pattern can override the label.
Source: Employment agreements guidance
When does fixed term actually make sense?
Fixed term suits work with a genuine end point you can name: covering someone's parental leave, a building contract with a completion date, a summer season at an orchard store, a grant-funded admin role that stops when the funding does. The agreement needs to say why it's fixed term, not just that it is one. If the "reason" disappears, for example the contract gets extended three times in a row with no real change in circumstances, the employee can argue it was permanent all along.
It also doesn't let you avoid minimum entitlements. Sick leave still kicks in after six months of continuous employment, and annual leave still builds toward four weeks after twelve months if the term runs that long.
Source: Sick leave entitlements
When does casual actually make sense?
Casual works for genuinely unpredictable demand: the odd Saturday extra in a bakery, a relief cleaner called in when someone's sick, a bar needing one more pair of hands for a one-off function. It does not work as a way to avoid giving someone regular hours you know you'll need every week. If you're rostering someone every Thursday and Friday for two months straight, that's not casual anymore in practice, whatever the contract says.
Casual employees still accrue entitlements based on hours actually worked, and KiwiSaver contributions still apply once they're eligible, at the employer minimum of 3%.
Source: KiwiSaver employer contributions
Comparison at a glance
- Fixed term: set hours, known end date or event, reason must be written into the agreement
- Casual: no guaranteed hours, shift by shift, employee can decline
- Fixed term: entitlements accrue the same as permanent while the term runs
- Casual: entitlements build on hours actually worked, often paid as 8% on top rather than accrued leave
- Both: get the agreement signed before the first day worked, every time
Key takeaways
- The reason for a fixed term has to be written into the agreement itself, a vague or recycled reason is what gets it reclassified as permanent
- Casual only holds up if the actual pattern of work is irregular, a regular roster under a casual label can be challenged
- Both agreement types still carry minimum entitlements like sick leave after six months and KiwiSaver at 3%
- Get the signed agreement in place before day one, not after, for either type
Frequently asked questions
Can I keep extending a fixed-term agreement instead of making someone permanent?
Repeated extensions with no genuine change in the underlying reason can mean the role is treated as permanent regardless of what the contract says. Each renewal should reflect a real, current reason, not just habit.
Does a casual employee get a 90-day trial?
Yes, the 90-day trial is available to employers of any size since December 2023, provided it's agreed in writing before the person starts their first shift, for casual and fixed-term hires alike.
Source: 90-day trial period rules
What happens if I call someone casual but roster them every week?
The label on the agreement doesn't override the actual pattern of work. If hours become regular and expected, an employee can argue the relationship is permanent in practice, with the entitlements that come with that.
Do I need a different agreement template for seasonal retail staff over Christmas?
Fixed term usually suits a named season better than casual, since you know roughly when it starts and ends. State the specific reason, such as "additional cover for the Christmas trading period ending [date]", rather than leaving it generic.
If you're hiring for a fixed-term or casual role right now, you can post the vacancy and create your free employer account to get it in front of NZ based applicants.